Lol. I'll reserve that judgement until after Odamex is fully functional and aqcuires enough of a following to go through a crisis or two.
It's always easier to protest an official response than it is to be the guys actually losing sleep and yanking out handfuls of hair in frustration trying to stem the latest disaster. Easier to tell someone else to turn the other cheek than to sit there taking punches with a smile.
I have pretty good feelings about the Odamex team, even ole carrot-top, and I'm prepared to give them a fair shake. Their arguments sound pretty good on paper [or maybe it's just the fabulous web design], and I'm all for the spirit of open-sourced development.
I'm also a big believer in human nature. ;p